January 27, 2007
Professional nosey parker
As a journalist I regularly get to poke my nose into other people’s business. Most of the time that business is related to their work or their area of expertise. For example, I’ll ask an air force pilot what it feels like to fly through the eye of a hurricane or I’ll find out why a professor has built a contraption to make people feel sick.
Sometimes though, I have to get personal and even though I’ve had plenty of practice and I’ve never been involved in any type of salacious snooping, it can sometimes seem a bit intrusive.
I’ve recently been working on a magazine story about scleroderma, a little-known disease that affects about 500 people in BC. I interviewed the doctor who heads up the clinic at St Paul’s hospital in Vancouver but I knew that a list of grim symptoms and talk of drug regimes wasn’t going to make an interesting read.
I had a thousand words to craft and I needed a sufferer with an interesting tale to tell. A willing victim was lined up and to my relief I didn’t have to prod and probe too much to get almost two decades worth of her personal and medical history. She was a great interviewee - I would ask a question and she would talk for a few minutes giving lots of facts and anecdotes. I learned all sorts of stuff about her life that I didn’t need to know but her openness gave my article heart. Her story is the thing that will engage the reader but I’ll get the credit with the byline.
Part of the reason for the article was to raise the profile of the disease but also raise money for research so there had to be a certain amount of tugging on the heartstrings. However, having spent time with the woman and listened to how she coped with her various ailments, I didn’t want to portray her as some enfeebled victim who was at the mercy of readers’ generosity. So I added an extra paragraph about how pro-active she was in local support groups and research programs. I’m pretty sure it will get cut as it’s not really pertinent to the story but I feel a little easing of my conscience.
Last year I wrote an article on dog theft and had to interview a couple of distraught dog owners. One was reluctant to talk so I really had to drag a few comments out of her. The other willingly sobbed down the phone about her “missing baby” while I sat there taking notes thinking this is gonna make great copy.
When I was a trainee reporter in Winchester in the UK, I used to have to go and do “death knocks”. Basically if somebody died and there was a good story in it, I had to go and knock on the door of the family and get a photo and a few quotes if possible. It was even better if I got their before the rival newspapers.
I despised doing it, but the thing that surprises me to this day, is that some people don’t mind the intrusion and were more than happy to talk about the person who had just died. Unfortunately, you never knew who was going to open up and who was going to slam the door in your face.
My first death knock involved a 6-year-old girl killed in a car accident. I reluctantly went to the parents’ house but no one was answering. As I walked away from the house the parents arrived and when I explained who I was, the grieving mother started wailing and the father started to shout. I apologised and left pretty pronto feeling like a real shit.
The next day, the senior editor insisted I go back and ask again as people sometimes change their mind. Being a wuss, or having a little bit of decency depending on your point of view, I couldn’t bring myself to go and knock on the door so I left a note with a business card. The next day I had an angry relative on the phone telling me to back off. After that I was under no more pressure to get a picture of that particular girl but if one had appeared in a rival newspaper I would have been asked to explain myself.
On another occasion, I rolled up a the house of a teenager who had been killed in a motorcycle accident. His parents welcomed me inside, got out the photo album and the memories started flowing. They were one of those families who wanted the world to know how great their son was and was glad someone was taking an interest. I still felt a bit bad intruding on their grief but I have to say, it made a nice story.
However worthy their intentions, all journalists are involved in some form of exploitation - and I’m not talking about the sort that is discussed in a J-school ethics class. You are constantly on the hunt for stories and contacts that will get you the next front page, career kudos or commission. It’s an unspoken rule that you ask people for information so you can earn your living. “Let me expose your pain or write about a dirty secret so I can steal a little bit of your glory.
Admittedly some exploit their own lives to make a living and with this blog, I’m exploiting myself but at least we have some control on the final result and I have no one to blame but myself.
YB